Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Census Routes

Pines Fire

Pines Fire

In the area burned by the Pines fire we established 32 survey routes plus 4 additional “control” routes in unburned habitat nearby outside the fire’s perimeter (see table and map). They study’s original design included more control routes, but some of these were burned in the Cedar fire in 2003. For comparison with conditions before the fire, the routes were coordinated with the grid for the San Diego County bird atlas, which surveyed the county on the basis of this framework from March 1997 to February 2002. Each route is contained within one grid square, although one square may contain more than one route. The routes’ elevations range from 2350 feet in San Felipe Valley to 5600 feet on the east flank of Hot Springs Mountain, 5353 feet on Volcan Mountain, and 5500 feet in the Laguna Mountains. Each route is between 1 and 2.5 miles long and was walked in a single morning as an unlimited-distance transect, with all birds seen and heard along the route recorded. Each route was designated by its atlas square, with an additional letter if more than one route was within the square. Each transect was covered by an experienced observer or team of observers on the following schedule through the spring and early summer: one survey between 15 April and 8 May, one survey between 9 May and 31 May, one survey between 1 June and 21 June, and one survey between 22 June and 15 July. Also, each transect was covered through the winter once in December, once in January, and once in February. Each survey of a given route was separated by at least one week. The routes were walked in the same direction each time and were generally covered by the same observer or team on every run. If the regular observer was not able to cover a route on the prescribed schedule, we arranged for a substitute. The study of the Pines fire area continued on this basis from December 2002 through July 2007, for five winters and five breeding seasons following the fire.

Pines Fire Route Table

  Elevation Length Observers
E22A 4300-4860 2145 J. K. Wilson, P. D. Jorgensen
E22B 4700-5100 2234 H. E. Stone, P. D. Jorgensen
F21 5160-5240 1576 P. D. Jorgensen, P. K. Nelson, K. Vega
G20B 3360-3420 3081 G. Grantham, K. Estey
G20C 3440-3640 1620 W. Pray, B. G. Anderson
G21C 4000-4240 5720 K. L. Weaver
G22A 4500-5030 3580 M. Bache, C. M. Manning
G22B 3300-3850 2328 H. Ingersoll
H20A 3620-4180 2170 M. B. Stowe
H20C 3470-3750 2040 G. Moreland, B. G. Anderson
H20D 2900-3160 2924 F. L. Unmack, J. K. Wilson, A. P. Keenan
H21A 3680-3890 3123 G. Moreland, B. Orr
H21C 3340-3890 2319 G. Moreland, B. Orr
I20A 3120-3600 1376 A. P. Keenan
I20B 3040-3230 1695 A. P. Keenan
I21B 2580-2880 3992 L. J. Hargrove, P. D. Jorgensen
J20 5010-5350 2396 L. E. Taylor, P. Unitt
K21B 2700-2800 2340 P. K. Nelson
K21C 2780-3640 4509 K. B. Clark
K21E 3440-3960 3900 J. O. Zimmer, E. C. Hall, J. R. Barth
K21F 3375-3600 1850 S. D. Cameron
L21A 3500-3870 2682 J. K. Wilson
L21C 4110-4700 5678 R. C. Sanger
L21D 4680-4770 1900 J. K. Wilson
L21E 4700-4850 1800 T. A. Blackman, K. Satterfield
L22B 2760-3250 2325 R. Thériault
M21B 4760-5080 3925 P. Unitt, A. Wright
M22A 4850-5350 4600 J. Determan, A. Compton
M22C 4140-5050 4736 R. & S. Breisch
N22 5270-5500 2350 S. Buchanan
N23 5400-5560 3250 K. J. Winter
  Elevation Length Observers
F21control 4560–5250 2232 T. A. Blackman, P. D. Jorgensen, K. Vega
G22control 3920–4120 2570 P. K. Nelson, R. C. Sanger
H22control 4120–4250 5009 M. B. Stowe
N23control 5340–5500 1450 K. J. Winter

Pines Fire Route Map

Pines Fire Route Map



In Cuyamaca Rancho State Park we established five survey routes in areas that were largely or entirely forested before the Cedar fire (see table and map). Their elevations range from 3930 feet at the Green Valley Falls campground to 6512 feet on the summit of Cuyamaca Peak. Because the Cuyamaca Mountains burned so extensively, there is no area in those mountains where an unburned route of similar length could be established. Therefore, we established a control route in Palomar Mountain State Park about 31 miles to the northwest. Its elevation ranges from 4460 to 5340 feet. The habitat along the Palomar route is also mixed conifer/oak forest but differs significantly, especially in the prevalence on north-facing slopes of the big-cone Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii), a tree absent from the Cuyamaca Mountains. Surveys of these routes began in April 2004 (thus excluding the winter immediately after the fire) and continued on the same schedule as the Pines fire routes.

Cuyamaca Route Map


Cleveland National Forest

In the Cleveland National Forest within the area burned in the Cedar fire we established four survey routes, three in burned areas (along or near Boulder Creek Road and Viejas Grade), one in an unburned area (along Bear Valley Road south of Pine Valley) (see table and map). The burned routes’ elevations range from 2700 feet along the trail to Eagle Peak off Boulder Creek Road to 3934 feet along Boulder Creek Road. The unburned route’s elevation ranges from 3880 at the north end of Bear Valley Road to 4390 feet at the top of the ridge east of Long Valley Peak. All four routes are similar in covering largely chaparral with a 15–25% exposure to groves of the coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia) or Engelmann oak (Q. engelmanni). Beginning in April 2005 Unitt surveyed all four of these routes on the same schedule as the Pines fire routes.

Bird Survey Routes for the Cedar Fire in Cleveland National Forest

  Elevation Length Habitats Observers
Boulder Cr. N 2700–3130 2749 Chaparral, Engelmann oak P. Unitt
Boulder Cr. S 3560-3950 2210 Chaparral, coast live oak P. Unitt
Viejas Grade 2830–3430 2993 Chaparral, Engelmann oak P. Unitt
Bear Valley Rd. 3880–4390 2561 Chaparral, coast live oak P. Unitt

Cedar Fire Route Map



We summed the counts of each species by condition of the route (burned or unburned), season, and year. Then we analyzed the results for each species by a three-step procedure, using chi-squared tests. For each species, we looked for a preference for burned or unburned habitat by pooling the results for all years, then (for the Pines fire) dividing the total for the burned routes by 8 (burned routes totaled 84.4 km, control routes 11.26 km), then testing for a significant difference by means of a chi-squared test.

Second, with another chi-squared test, we searched for trends, testing for a significant departure from a uniform distribution over the 5 years, each season and each condition (burned or unburned) considered separately. Because numbers of some species followed a pronounced see-saw pattern, we believe this method was more appropriate than a regression analysis that assumes a unidirectional trend. We categorized each species by its pattern of change, assigning it to the simplest pattern identified as significant by the chi-squared tests.

Third, also with a chi-squared test, we compared the change along the burned routes to the change along the control routes to see if these patterns differed significantly. In the Pines fire area, where the routes were coordinated with the atlas squares, we compared the number of squares in which the species was recorded before the fire with the number in which it was recorded each year after the fire. Because at 17 the number of squares surveyed is rather low, any difference had to be large to be considered significant under a chi-squared test. This comparison is coarse, but significant differences thus represented major changes before and after the fire.